The RONA Story: "Truly Canadian" Again. Will the Contractors Walk Back In?
- Shannon Peel
- 6 days ago
- 13 min read
by Shannon Peel | Brand Narrative Builder
This is the story of RONA, a brand born out of defiance, built through decades of trust, stripped of its identity by a US giant, and is now trying to remember what made it matter to Canadian shoppers in the first place.
Pull up a chair.
It Started as a Fight
The year was 1939. A group of roughly 30 independent hardware store owners in Quebec were being squeezed by a monopoly that controlled their access to supplies. They had two choices: compete alone and likely lose, or band together and fight back.
They chose to fight.
On October 6, 1939, those Montreal-area hardware retailers founded "Les Marchands en Quincaillerie," which translates roughly to The Merchants of Hardware, creating the alliance specifically to bypass wholesale distributors and deal directly with manufacturers to combat a monopoly threatening their supply chains.
It was a cooperative, not a corporation. Every store owner retained their independence while sharing the buying power that let them survive.
On July 20, 1960, the company changed the name to RONA and was mainly a regional success story in Quebec and eastern Canada.
How Revy Became Part of the RONA Story
Home Depot entered the Canadian market in 1994 by acquiring an Ontario chain called Aikenhead's Home Improvement Warehouse, and between 1993 and 2001, 34 big-box stores opened in the Toronto area while 117 traditional-sized stores closed. The message was clear: adapt to big-box or disappear.
RONA, now called RONA Dismat after a series of internal evolutions, saw the writing on the wall, be a big fish or get eaten by the biggest one swimming in new waters. The company made a decision to grow larger through acquisition, accepting an investment of $30 million from the French hardware chain ITM Enterprises in 1997 to bankroll its expansion, then changing its name to RONA Inc. in 1998. The cooperative spirit was giving way to corporate ambition, and for a while, that ambition worked.
In 2000, the company spent $50 million on a chain of 66 Ontario hardware stores called Cashway Building Centres. Then came the move that reshaped RONA's geographic footprint entirely. In 2001, RONA acquired 51 Revy Home and Garden stores (based in British Columbia), Revelstoke Home Centres (located in Western Canada), and Lansing Building Supply (based in North York, Ontario since 1951). It also acquired Réno-Dépôt, which included The Building Box, 20 big-box stores in Quebec and Ontario, as well as 16 Totem Building Supplies stores in Alberta. They were now a national chain positioned to compete with the big American kid who moved onto their block.
In November 2002, RONA took another major step and went public, concluding an initial public offering on the Toronto Stock Exchange under the symbol RON.
By the mid-2000s, RONA was no longer a small Quebec cooperative. It was a national retailer with hundreds of stores, a public stock, and revenues that had climbed past $4 billion. The name Revy disappeared into the RONA banner. Other banners were absorbed, renamed, or retired. RONA was the flag it all flew under. And for a while, Canadians shopped there.
The First Time Lowes Tried to Buy RONA
Here is where things get interesting, and where the brand story starts to get complicated.
In 2012, Lowe's attempted to buy RONA; however, the deal was met with objections from RONA shareholders, particularly the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, and franchisees, and was eventually called off.
Think about what that moment meant. The Caisse de Dépôt, Quebec's massive institutional investor and pension fund, was not going to let a US retailer walk in and absorb one of the province's most beloved brands without a fight. The franchisees, those independent store owners who still traced their lineage back to the original cooperative, pushed back hard. RONA survived that first attempt, but it was a warning shot.
When Lowe's Finally Got What It Wanted
Four years later, RONA's stock was struggling, its leadership had changed, and the same deal that shareholders blocked in 2012 came back at a different number with a different board.
On February 3, 2016, Lowe's and RONA announced a definitive agreement under which Lowe's would acquire all of RONA's outstanding shares at C$24 per share in cash, a total transaction value of C$3.2 billion or US$2.3 billion, representing a premium of 104 percent to RONA's closing share price the day before the announcement. That premium was significant. At that moment, RONA shareholders made a rational financial decision. Whether it was the right strategic decision for the brand is another question entirely.
Why did Lowe's want RONA so badly?
The acquisition created one of the largest home improvement retailers in Canada, with 539 store locations and pro-forma revenues from Canadian operations of approximately C$6 billion, serving Canada's home improvement market valued at over C$45 billion. For Lowe's, which had been slowly building a Canadian presence since 2007 but never achieved meaningful market share against Home Depot, RONA was the shortcut. It was an established network, a trusted name, and a market entry that would have taken decades to build organically.
Lowe's Chairman, President and CEO Robert A. Niblock said the transaction was expected to "accelerate Lowe's growth strategy by significantly expanding our presence in the Canadian market through the addition of RONA's attractive business and excellent store locations across the country."
He got the locations. What he did not understand, or chose not to prioritize, was the brand experience those locations represented.
How the Brand Lost Its Canadian Identity
The Lowe's era began with promises, and for a moment it looked like those promises might hold. The Canadian head office stayed in Boucherville, Quebec. Canadian leadership stayed in place. The RONA name survived on mid-sized stores. But the cracks appeared quickly, and they ran deep.
Just six months after acquiring RONA, Lowe's announced plans to convert 40 RONA stores outside Quebec to the Lowe's name, as part of a plan to differentiate the offering in big-box stores, which would bear the Lowe's name, from mid-sized stores, which would continue to be called RONA. The message was already mixed.
Some stores RONA, some stores Lowe's, no brand consistency. They were trying to differentiate the two by focusing on differnet markets but with decisions for both being made by the same people. This didn't work for Best Buy & Future Shop and it wasn't going to work for Lowe's & RONA either.
The company adopted a new structure comprised of four business units: Big Box, Proximity, Pros and Contractors, and Affiliate Dealers, repositioning the RONA banner with the goal of making it the number one retailer in the proximity store market, which accounted for about 56 percent of the home improvement market in Canada. That strategy was not wrong, but what got lost in translation was everything that made RONA feel Canadian to the people walking through its doors.
Then came the most damaging moment of all, and it is the kind of moment that a brand cannot simply walk back.
RONA, which had long considered itself a Canadian icon, had pasted the words "Truly Canadian" and "Proudly Canadian" in large letters on many of its storefronts, but was forced to remove those signs after Canada's Ad Standards council found they "conveyed an inaccurate general impression" given the company's new American ownership.
RONA fought the ruling by tracing "the Canadian roots of RONA, its many Canadian connections, and the number of high-level employees in RONA's Canadian operations, who are Canadian." The council's decision was clear: "But it did not alter the fact that RONA is not owned and controlled by a 'Truly Canadian' entity." The ownership must be Canadian is the same logic they use in the entertainment industry, which mandates CBC must bankroll Canadian owned shows and productions.
In trying to protect the Canadianess of ownership, our laws and rules make it hard for Canadians running companies in Canada owned by a foreign investor or company. This is a handicap in today's "Buy Canadian" atmosphere. What makes a company or product Canadian? According to the rules, ownership.
Brands do not just live in logos and colour palettes. They live in the stories people tell about them. When your customers start telling the story that you are no longer who you said you were, the damage compounds daily, and no amount of ad spend fixes it.
If a brand does not manage expectations, they will end up with bad reviews and declining brand value as their reputation takes a beating.
The Contractor Customer: How RONA Lost Its Most Loyal Buyer
The erosion of the brand relationship between RONA and their loyal contractor customers started before Lowe's walked through the door.
In 2012, when Lowe's made its first unsolicited bid for RONA, the company that pushed back was not just a hardware retailer. RONA was a leader in the specialized plumbing and HVAC market, primarily serving commercial and professional customers with a network of close to 60 sales outlets and four distribution centres across the country. That was a serious, dedicated contractor supply business sitting inside the retail operation, and it was exactly the kind of depth that made RONA different from every other store with a lumber aisle
One year after blocking Lowe's, RONA sold it and their market value decreased.
RONA sold its entire Commercial and Professional Market division, operating under the Noble, Don Park, MPH Supplies, Boutique Eaudace and Boutique Plomberie Décoration banners, to London, Ontario-based EMCO, netting approximately $215 million. The money went toward survival, paying down debt and funding store closures in a company that was struggling under years of overexpansion. This is the same issue that Cirque d'Soili, Mountain Equipment Co-op, and WestJet experienced. Growing and becoming overextended then having to give up something that gaves the brand its value.
One analyst did not mince words about what the sale represented. "What we're really seeing here is another case of Rona shrinking for growth," said Derek Dley of Canaccord Genuity, adding that the moves represented a reversal of its prior direction by closing stores and selling the professional and commercial division which it had identified as a core growth area only two years earlier.
So when Lowe's completed the acquisition in 2016, it inherited a contractor-oriented retail chain that had already stripped out its most sophisticated contractor-serving capabilities. The deep plumbing, HVAC, and mechanical trade supply infrastructure that genuinely differentiated RONA from Home Depot was already gone.
Lowe's did not dismantle it. RONA dismantled it itself.
What Lowe's did next made things worse.
The stores that converted to the Lowe's banner added Whirlpool appliances, Kohler fixtures, John Deere outdoor power equipment, and Lowe's American private-label brands like Kobalt tools and Allen & Roth home décor, categories that meant nothing to a framing contractor ordering roofing, drywall, and insulation by the pallet. Converting RONA stores to the Lowe's banner included an expanded product assortment, as well as the introduction of new categories, along with Lowe's established private label brands. The store was physically becoming something a contractor did not need, while the products a contractor did need were either reduced in depth or harder to find among the new home décor and seasonal patio collections.
The RONA stores that kept their banner were to serve the contractor.
On paper, some of them got real investment. The new RONA building centre model included a reserved parking area, dedicated entrance and service desk, extended business hours to fit contractors' schedules, a special fleet of trucks for construction site deliveries, a minimum 15,000-square-foot drive-through lumberyard, and charge-account services to speed up and simplify purchasing. A handful of locations in Etobicoke and Leduc actually got the full service for contractors treatment. But a handful is not a network.
When Lowe's began closing underperforming stores in 2018 and 2019, the closures were not random. Of the 31 locations Lowe's closed in Canada in 2018, 27 were RONA stores. The contractor-focused RONA locations in smaller markets, exactly the stores that served trades in communities where Home Depot had no presence, were disproportionately the ones deemed underperforming and shut down.
Then there was the independent dealer network, which was the community-level contractor relationship backbone of the entire RONA brand. Those independent store owners, many of whom still traced their lineage back to the original cooperative spirit of 1939, had been growing anxious throughout the Lowe's era.
Many of RONA's independent dealers were expected to end their contracts with Lowe's Canada and look for new buying groups to ally themselves with, such as Castle Building Centres Group, Groupe BMR, or Home Hardware. "It's going to be shark week," said Michael McLarney, a hardware industry specialist who runs trade publication Hardlines. "The other groups are going to be circling trying to get these Rona dealers to convert."
Those dealers were often the last touchpoint a local contractor had with the RONA brand. When they left, they took their customers with them.
The contractors did not abandon RONA all at once. They left gradually, each time they walked in looking for depth of product and trade expertise and found a store that was trying to be something else. That is how you lose a loyal customer who has been buying from you for decades. Not with one bad decision, but with a long series of small signals that tell them they no longer matter as much as the person buying a patio set.
Why Lowe's Lost Money on RONA
Lowe's paid C$3.2 billion for RONA in 2016. It sold the Canadian business for US$400 million in 2022. That is not a typo. That is one of the more spectacular destructions of brand value in Canadian retail history.
In November 2019, Lowe's announced the closure of 34 stores across Canada, with acting president Tony Cioffi confirming the stores were underperforming and that their closure would help reveal the margin of manoeuvre the hardware store said it needed to reinvest in its future growth.
The store count was shrinking before the pandemic. Then during the pandemic, when home improvement was booming everywhere, the structural problems in the Canadian Lowe's operations were temporarily masked by consumer demand. When that demand normalized, the underlying weaknesses were still there.
Lowe's entered the Canadian market in 2007 and expanded its footprint in 2016 with the purchase of RONA for $3.2 billion. The sale in 2022 was a recognition by the company that it could not make the takeover work. The business had struggled and Lowe's had cut jobs and closed dozens of stores in several provinces.
Lowe's became the latest company to prove that cross-border expansion between Canada and the United States is not always as easy as it seems. The retail landscape is littered with companies based in both countries that have pulled back, including Target and Walmart's Sam's Club.
The strategic misread was cultural as much as financial.
Lowe's core customer in the United States was the DIY homeowner, particularly women and first-time homeowners, a segment that the brand had built its US identity around. RONA's historic strength was with contractors, builders, and the kind of Canadian who knows the difference between a joist and a rafter. Those are different customers with different needs and different loyalties. When Lowe's layered its US identity onto a brand that served a different customer, it satisfied neither.
Who Bought RONA, and What Have They Done With It?
On February 3, 2023, Sycamore Partners, a private equity firm specializing in retail, consumer, and distribution-related investments, announced the completion of its acquisition of Lowe's Canadian retail business, which would now operate under the name RONA inc., with headquarters in Boucherville, Quebec.
Sycamore's managing director Stefan Kaluzny said at the time, "We are excited to announce that RONA is once again an independent company headquartered in Boucherville, Quebec. We are honoured that Lowe's has entrusted Sycamore Partners to lead RONA into its next chapter and build upon RONA's 84-year history serving communities across Canada."
The first order of business was simplification. The RONA+ concept first launched in Ontario in July 2023 with the conversion of 10 Lowe's stores. By February 2024, all Lowe's stores in Canada had been transitioned to RONA+, officially retiring the Lowe's brand from the Canadian market.
The strategy was to consolidate a confusing mess of banners, Lowe's, RONA, Réno-Dépôt, Dick's Lumber, into something a Canadian customer could understand and trust again.
RONA re-established itself as an independent Canadian company, quickly moving to simplify a complex network of banners, with the strategy focused on restoring a clear Canadian identity while improving operational efficiency and reducing customer confusion.
The brand also made a strategic acquisition that signalled its intent to grow where RONA always had its deepest roots: with professionals. Sycamore Partners, together with RONA inc., announced the acquisition of All-Fab Group, one of the largest building solutions providers across Western Canada, which has served the needs of building contractors, building owners, and dealers across Western Canada for over 50 years.
And then, in early 2025, something unexpected happened that gave RONA a brand opportunity it could never have manufactured on its own.
US tariff threats from President Donald Trump in early 2025 generated a surge in pro-Canada sentiment, raising the stakes for a brand trying to re-establish its Canadian identity. When Canadians started choosing Canadian brands deliberately, when "Buy Canadian" moved from a niche preference to a mainstream conversation, RONA was in the process of doing exactly what resonated with that moment: reclaiming its Canadian identity after years of foreign ownership.
RONA's chief marketing and digital officer Catherine Laporte, promoted to the role in July 2025 after joining the company in 2018, was direct about what the Lowe's era had cost the brand. She told Strategy magazine that when the American company acquired RONA ten years earlier, "we lost a lot of love and a lot of trust" among French-speaking Canadians, adding that "Lowe's just didn't invest as much within the RONA brand."
That is the understatement of a decade.
Can RONA Come Back?
The honest answer is: it depends on what "back" means.
If back means returning to being the dominant national home improvement retailer with $4.5 billion in annual revenues, a public stock, and a coast-to-coast network built through decades of organic growth and strategic acquisition, that RONA is probably not coming back. The market is different. Home Depot is deeply entrenched in English Canada. The independent dealer model that made RONA's cooperative roots meaningful has been steadily eroded across all of retail for 30 years.
But if back means rebuilding trust, reclaiming a clear identity, and earning back the customers who watched their store get Americanized and felt a quiet, low-grade betrayal every time they walked past a sign that said "Truly Canadian" and knew it was a lie, that RONA has a real shot.
RONA's positioning in the Canadian market is no longer about beating Home Depot at its own game. It is about owning the segment Home Depot does not optimize for, the proximity and building centre market, where contractors and local trades need a fast, nearby supply run rather than a destination big-box trip. RONA is leaning hard into a Canadian-identity story it can tell with more credibility than any of its rivals, an 87-year-old brand that started as a cooperative of independent merchants fighting a monopoly, and is now rebuilding that same dealer-owned network and contractor depth under a unified RONA+ banner.
Strategically, that means RONA is not trying to out-scale Canadian Tire or out-spend Home Depot. It is trying to out-trust them, betting that a brand which can credibly say it is Canadian-owned, contractor-first, and locally rooted will win the loyalty, especially in a market where Canadians are actively looking for reasons to choose homegrown over imported. The risk is that this positioning only works if the in-store experience backs it up, and right now the evidence on operational consistency is still catching up to the story being told.
Shannon Peel is a Brand Narrative Strategist who helps Canadian businesses build brand authority and tell stories that build trust. She publishes analysis on Canadian business, brand strategy, and the stories behind the brands Canadians live with every day.
Comments